The Ball Grid The Ball Grid
Back to the game

Why Harry Maguire tops the wrong-answer list

By The Ball Grid ·

The most-wrong name of the month is also, most of the time, a right one.

Over the last 30 days, Harry Maguire was the name entered most often and marked wrong: 246 wrong answers. That figure looks like a story about a bad guess, but the rest of his record says otherwise. He was entered 670 times in the period, and 424 of those entries were correct, a success rate of 63.3%.

Volume, not error

Topping the wrong-answer list does not take a poor hit rate. It takes a lot of attempts. A name entered 670 times will pile up wrong answers even if most entries land. Maguire's 246 misses come from players reaching for him far more often than for almost anyone else, not from his name being a bad bet.

The contrast with the most reliably correct names makes the point. Nick Woltemade was right 88.7% of the time across 142 entries. Benjamin Šeško managed 82.9% of 123, Ayden Heaven 81.7% of 109, Shea Lacey 89.8% of 59 and Patrick Chinazaekpere Dorgu 93.3% of 30. All of them were entered far fewer times than Maguire's 670. A smaller pool of entries leaves less room for wrong answers to build up, and these tend to be names players pick when they are fairly sure of the fit.

The square decides, not the name

The cell-by-cell breakdown shows where he was tried:

In every listed cell, all entries went the same way. Within a square, Maguire's name is never a coin flip: it either fits that pair of conditions or it does not, for every player who tries it. The 63.3% overall is not a measure of how likely he is to be right in any one place. It is an average across squares that are either always right or always wrong.

The cells also show what draws players to him. Three of the five involve Manchester United, two involve height over 185cm, and the others ask for a defender or a player over 30 at season start. His name comes to mind quickly for a whole cluster of conditions. That reach is what produces the 670 entries, and it is also why the wrong answers stack up whenever the square asks for something he does not fit.

What it means for a player

A name that feels right for many squares is a strong first instinct, but the instinct does not carry from one square to the next. Each cell pairs two conditions, and the season label matters: the Manchester United cells here are split between 2024/25 and 2025/26. Checking both conditions and the season before committing is the difference between a cell that goes 57 of 57 one way and one that goes the other.

The figures show where the name was entered and how each entry was marked, but not why individual players chose it.

Figures drawn from 83,149 recorded answers on The Ball Grid. Play today's grid.

Play today’s Premier League grid →

More analysis

← All analysis